I don't use lip liners so that's why I didn't pick any up. These are both great but if you were to buy one, I would tell you to go for one with a matte finish. The pigmentation is just incredible and they are so creamy and smooth. If you are at all intrigued, I would recommend anything from this brand. For $5, you won't find any other products this high quality.
https://colourpop.com/